Scariest Movies to Stream on Prime Video

Amazon Prime Video’s horror section isn’t its most robust feature, but there is still a very strong presence when it comes to horror films across the decades. Throwing in a little bit of the old alongside the new makes it an underrated platform for fans looking to catch up on some scares, as well as sporting some of the all-time classics that anyone new to the genre would have on their must-watch list. While we’re looking forward to it developing further, these are some of the creepiest, cringiest, and outright scariest the service has to offer.

Train to Busan (2016)

train to busan scaled
Courtesy of Next Entertainment World

When a chemical spill causes the zombie apocalypse to break out, passengers on a train from Seoul to Busan are trapped in different compartments as the other cars quickly fill with zombies. Every time the train stops, they are besieged by new undead, even at supposed safe zones. Separated from their friends and family, the group desperately tries to reach the other survivors, and a lot of them don’t make it to the end of the film. The zombies here are among the scariest in recent memory, and the fast pace, social commentary, and solid characterization makes it feel like a season of a TV series packed into a feature-length film.

 

The Lighthouse (2019)

Horror Movies to Stream on Amazon Prime
Courtesy of A24

The feeling of isolation is one of the scariest things there is, but it’s also something that many horror films, often watched with others or at the very least filmed as group endeavors, have struggled to convey. This film succeeds by giving us a pair of lighthouse keepers, allowing the distant interactions between them to serve as the isolating factor. Introducing us to two very strange men working in tandem, the dynamic between Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson are what makes this movie click. The Lighthouse is a nightmarish slow burn made for fans of psychological horror.

V/H/S (2012)

vhs
Courtesy of Bloody Disgusting

Found footage has been a popular genre for filmmakers at least since the release of The Blair Witch Project in 1999, and V/H/S is one of the best. Told in classic horror anthology style with a framing story to support a series of vignettes, we meet a group of criminals breaking into houses that find a disturbing room full of cryptically labeled VHS tapes. Popping them into the player to see what secrets they hold, the central character is horrified by what he finds. Though this ultimately became a franchise of diminishing returns, there is always something a little bit unnerving in each of these films. Still, there’s no outdoing the first.

Better Watch Out (2016)

better watch out movie scaled
Courtesy of Storm Vision

Flipping the script on the babysitter who is forced to protect the children in her care, Better Watch Out gives us a protagonist who is fighting to survive the boy she’s tasked with watching over. Set during the holidays, a 17-year-old is asked to keep an eye on a 12-year-old who has a crush on her. Setting up an elaborate plan to scare her so that she’ll view him as her hero, the plan quickly falls apart only to see him go into full villain mode. Toying with the idea of a privileged young man tormenting a girl that rejects him while adding various subversions as the film goes along, this is a movie packed with unsettling moments both horror-related and not.

The Collector (2009)

the collector
Courtesy of Fortress Features

Home invasion is one of the scariest things that could possibly happen to a person, and the horror genre is rife with stories based on the terror that comes from being caught off-guard by an attacker. Subversions to the trope are always welcome, which is why The Collector remains such a great movie. In an attempt to protect his wife, the groundskeeper for the Chase family plans to break in and steal a single item to help her make her payment to a loan shark. However, when he arrives, he discovers that someone far more dangerous has already set their sights on the home, forcing him into a fight for survival along with the family he intended to betray.

Suspiria (2018)

Essential Halloween Movies
Courtesy of Amazon Studios

The original Suspiria is considered one of the classics of the genre, which is why the prospect of a remake brought with it a level of apprehension from fans. The way the film managed to undermine that was by creating a totally different film, sharing similar aesthetics and atmosphere but existing very much as its own thing. There’s no question that this is a polarizing entry, but there is a lot to unpack in its scenes which heightens its rewatch factor. Its lean into the perfectionism demanded of students of many vocations creates an upsetting and surreal backdrop that manages to still pay some fanservice by including easter eggs and a delightful if brief cameo from the star of the original film, Jessica Harper.

XX (2017)

xx movie scaled
Courtesy of XYZ Films

Another anthology, this movie focuses on drawing women directors including Sofia Carrillo, Jovanka Vuckovic, Annie Clark, Roxanne Benjamin, and Karyn Kusama together to tell various horror stories. Framed with surreal stop motion segments, the stories range from standard fear-of-the-unknown style scares to more complex interrelationship dynamics. The highlight of the series is The Birthday Party, in which a housewife played by Melanie Lynskey feels compelled to hide her husband’s body when he dies, but all these stories are good. Rather than creating a shared aesthetic like V/H/S, XX thrives by letting each storyteller do their own thing.

When A Stranger Calls (1979)

when a stranger calls scaled
Courtesy of Columbia Pictures

Fans of the Scream franchise may find interest in the movie with an opening sequence that went on to inspire the iconic intro of the 1996 film. Yet, When A Stranger Calls is a unique movie. While Scream used its opening scene to embrace horror tropes, Stranger seems to eschew them at every turn. Featuring an underrated performance from the great Carol Kane, the story begins with the babysitter tormented by a mysterious caller only to switch tracks twenty minutes in to focus on the life of her tormentor after he escapes from prison years later. Never sympathizing with him but likewise failing to fully condemn a man created very much by an uncaring society, the movie is often criticized for going off the rails, but for some, that is its strength. In conjunction with its highly underrated sequel When A Stranger Calls Back, the story thrives as a commentary on the long-lasting effects of trauma.

Hellraiser (1987)

hellraiser
Courtesy of Entertainment Film Distributors

Clive Barker’s Hellraiser is one of the most influential horror films ever, and it has a pending TV series that will see his return to the franchise after it fully flew off the rails for a long while. That means there’s no time like the present for a first viewing or a rewatch of the film that gifted us with the cenobites. Often reduced in the popular imagination to being a movie about a guy with a bunch of pins in his head, this movie gave us one of the most interesting among the final girls with the fast-thinking Kirsty Cotton and an excellent supervillain with her stepmother, Julia.

Children of the Corn (1984)

children of the corn
Courtesy of New World Pictures

A couple traveling through rural Nebraska hits a small child as he runs out from a cornfield, confused by the circumstances but not understanding that the kid was fleeing for his life. They go to town to find help, but it seems abandoned. Attempting to fuel up only to be refused by an attendant, it becomes clear that there’s something gravely amiss. Even at that, a corn-worshipping cult full of children that murdered all the adults in town probably wasn’t on anyone’s bingo card, so the couple spends much of the movie completely out of their element. That sense of unspoken terror is a major part of why this is such a widely influential film. Moments of low-budget cheese aside, the creepy premise and performances are what holds the story together.

The Wailing (2016)

the wailing scaled
Courtesy of Fox International Productions

When a detective is sent to a small town in South Korea to investigate a series of murders, he has no idea what kind of supernatural horror he’s getting himself involved in. As he attempts to save his daughter’s life, he comes up against a plague that seems to turn people into murderous monsters. The Wailing is sometimes funny, sometimes brutal, but it excels by leaning away from moralizing. Presenting a series of highly flawed characters that are doing their best in unreal circumstances, the best part of the film is the way it refuses to grant anyone a no-strings-attached happy ending. Ruminating on the kind of evils that can’t be quelled by a good guy in a cape, The Wailing is one of the best horror movies ever made, but it’s not an easy ride.

Daniel Isn’t Real (2019)

daniel isn real
Courtesy of SpectreVision

Luke is a shy kid who befriends the much more confident Daniel in childhood. Dismissed as an imaginary friend, Daniel is initially helpful but ultimately demands that Luke do increasingly bad things. Temporarily locking him away when he gets out of hand, Luke inadvertently frees him only to see Daniel gain the ability to take over his body and control him. Utilizing the classic fear of lack of possession to tell a story about a troubled, lonely young man, this is one of the better horror films released in recent years.

Phantasm (1979)

phantasam
Courtesy of New Breed Productions

The first entry in what was to become one of the most notable horror franchises of its era, Phantasm introduces the world to the villainous Tall Man. This is an alien undertaker that turns the dead into zombies to send back to his home planet. Though Phantasm is a movie that runs low on cohesive plot, it rates high on terror as our antagonist mows down anyone that gets in his way. Utilizing a spherical flying device called a Sentinel to kill bystanders in increasingly brutal ways, the Tall Man remains one of the most disturbing villains of any age.

House on Haunted Hill (1959)

house on haunted hill
Courtesy of Warner Bros.

The films of producer and director William Castle are generally known for their marketing gimmicks, but that’s not to say his films were completely without appeal for more serious horror aficionados. Rating high among his filmography is House on Haunted Hill, which takes the concept of a group of people spending the night in a famously haunted house to a new extreme. Brought together by a wealthy man who dares the group to stay by offering them a large sum of money if they make it through the night, this film leaned into the schlock by incorporating carnival standbys like fake skeletons and optical illusions to deliver real scares.

Bit (2019)

bit
Courtesy of Vertical Entertainment

The teenage Laurel moves to LA, rooming with her more-or-less estranged brother Mark. On her first night in town, she ends up smack dab in the middle of vampire drama when she meets a girl gang that ushers her into their crew. Undergoing many of the same coming-of-age problems that anyone deals with only vampire-style, Laurel has to figure out how to go her own way. Though admittedly more a comedy than a straightforward horror film, this still has some worthy scares.

Let the Right One In (2008)

let the right one in
Courtesy of EFTI

The bullied Oskar meets Eli, who has the appearance of a girl about his age. As the two form a tender friendship based on mutual support, Oskar realizes that there is a lot more to Eli than he initially thought. A vampire who can never age, Eli alternately disturbs and intrigues Oskar. Together, they form one of the strangest and most endearing friendships in horror history.

Dead and Buried (1981)

dead and buried
Courtesy of AVCO Embassy Pictures

This is a lesser-known gem, but it’s a surprisingly brutal one. Opening on a traveling photographer who is beaten and set aflame by locals, the story then pans to a detective working alongside a coroner-mortician to solve a series of murders. With his wife acting increasingly strange, the detective hits a number of brick walls as he tries to understand what’s happening. Graphic and gory, this is not for the faint of heart, but it’s a lot of fun for fans of the bleaker side of the genre.

Black Death (2010)

black death
Courtesy of Revolver Entertainment

Black Death takes it back to medieval England to a countryside ravaged by the plague. An idealistic monk joins a group of soldiers to investigate a remote town that is rumored to be unaffected by the plague. Along the way, they witness endless horrors. Throughout the ongoing pandemic of the last couple years, this movie has become only scarier as the theoretical abandonment of people in need that the film presents has an uneasy echo in modern times.

The Most Dangerous Game (1932)

most dangerous game
Courtesy of RKO Radio Pictures

Filmed at night on the same sets with much of the same crew as King Kong, this is a movie in which the monster is man. A big-game hunter is apparently the only survivor when a boat he’s traveling on capsizes. Believing himself fortunate when he finds himself washed ashore on an eccentric millionaire’s island, he quickly learns that’s anything but the truth as he learns that man is “the most dangerous game.” This story has been referenced, parodied, and remade many times over, but the original still serves substantial chills.

Woe (2020)

woe scaled
Courtesy of Matthew Goodhue

Of all the many genres of fiction, few grapple with grief and trauma head-on in the way that horror does. Among the countless examples of this, Woe is near the top. Led by great performances, the story tells of two siblings suffering the recent loss of their father. Both stressed and disturbed generally, the death in their family has only served to further isolate them both. Feelings of repetition and mundanity haunt the siblings and trap them in a loop, which reflects the way days can blend together when suffering emotional fallout from a great loss. All the while, they’re stalked by Death themselves.

More From Wealth of Geeks

This post was produced and syndicated by Wealth of Geeks.

Image Credit: Maggie Lovitt. 


+ posts

Sara is a horror writer, a critic, a reporter, a filmmaker, and an artist that has written for many publications and platforms. She is the co-host of the Bitches On Comics podcast as well as the co-founder and editor of the Decoded Pride anthology which focuses on works of queer speculative fiction.