The Quiet Girl Speaks Loudly With Hushed Performances

The Quiet Girl (An Cailín Ciúin) finds depth in silence, chiseling out potent emotional points contrasted with a serene yet vibrant Ireland country backdrop. Written and directed by Colm Bairéad, the story follows quiet, withdrawn nine-year-old Cáit (Catherine Clinch), sent away with distant relatives over the summer. Not a coming-of-age story; it’s a tale of blossoming into one’s self. Subdued performances capture the essence of the film’s title; The Quiet Girl brings loss, sorrow, and beauty to life through hushed moments.

A Dysfunctional Home Where Silence Is Best

Cáit’s home life is one of anxiousness. Her pregnant mom (Kate Nic Chonaonaigh) and dad (Michael Patric) have a rocky relationship. Their precarious finances, due to her father’s gambling habit plus his infidelity, do not help. None of them talk to her throughout the morning except her mom, who criticizes her muddy shoes.  The full breadth of her home life is shrouded in mist, inferred only from moments.

Here, The Quiet Girl speaks volumes as her sisters gossip, then fall abruptly silent as their father enters. In this family, it appears silence is best. But Cáit, dubbed “the wanderer” by her father, also has a penchant for leaving to avoid trouble, such as hiding after she wet the bed. Her sisters blame her for their empty lunch boxes though it’s unclear if her mom forgot to pack them due to worry. Whether physical abuse exists doesn’t alter the fact neglect is abusive. Their dad is a deadbeat with no praise for his offspring, and their mom, swamped with responsibilities, lacks kind words too.

Care and Attention Matter

Overwhelmed with kids, Cáit mom sends her to a cousin’s home for the summer. Upon arrival, it’s clear her mom’s cousin Eibhlín (Carrie Crowley), and Eibhlín’s gruff husband Seán (Andrew Bennett) dislike Cáit’s father. Eibhlín’s grace and immediate gentleness toward Cáit make choosing allegiances between Eibhlín and Cáit’s father easy to decide. After some subtext-laden conversation that flies over Cáit’s head, her father departs. In his rush to dump his child with strangers, he leaves with Cáit’s suitcase. As they lend Cáit clothes to wear, which fit her surprisingly well, an underlying question arises about why they have children’s attire.

Cáit’s arc does not alter her character but allows her to be more herself. Similar situations like wetting the bed play out in her temporary new residence. Yet Eibhlín’s response builds a slow trust between the pair. Even Cáit’s silence, deemed problematic by many, is a strength to withdrawn Seán as he warms to Cáit. Seán is that monosyllabic grandfather that rarely converses with children. But his aloof demeanor holds more, and Bairéad steadily delves into this masterfully. Though not a dark film, it sets up a level of foreboding tied to this couple’s past that builds worry too.

Stellar Direction and Perfect Casting Brings This Gem to Life

Colm Bairéad’s first feature is moving, and as breathtaking as the expanse of greenery Cáit finds herself in when staying with older couple Eibhlín and Seán. The director uses small moments to tell an emotional tale vaster than what appears onscreen. Lingering on an object or individual, Bairéad understands how to time these for maximum effect. Though subdued in every aspect, you yell at the screen, feeling the underlying emotional weight of riveting moments yourself.

Newcomer Catherine Clinch astounds in her role, balancing innocence, sadness, and reticence. Carrie Crowley’s warmth wrapped in elegance gives a regal quality, and Andrew Bennett perfectly counters it with his taciturn yet fearful performance. The trio conveys so much through their expressions and simple actions. Although Kate Nic Chonaonaigh and Michael Patric have less screen time, both epitomize their roles. The former shows a beleaguered disregard for her kids that’s unintentional but results from being overwhelmed by responsibility. The latter portrays a misplaced condescension that leaves you furious at his character.

The Quiet Girl does not indict the parents’ neglect. It emphasizes the importance of care and gentle handling in children’s formative years. There is no resolution at the end, leaving it open to viewers’ fears and hopes. But whether it was only a few short months, there is a heartwarming and lasting impact on the lives of all three. Seeing Cáit’s change from the film’s outset to the end is stunning. The Quiet Girl takes a familiar story and brings an underlying current of depth with nuanced, spectacular performances and splendid directing.

Rating: 8/10 SPECS

We've got the latest on all the movies in theaters now.

This article was produced and syndicated by Wealth of Geeks.