Chris Columbus has revisited the only time he says he fired an actor, describing a performer briefly hired to play Marv in Home Alone as “awful.” The director’s recollection has prompted a response from Daniel Roebuck.
Columbus discussed the casting during the November 17 episode of Wildmen, hosted by Dylan Sprouse and the filmmaker’s son, Brendan Columbus.
Although Columbus did not identify the actor, Roebuck has long acknowledged his brief involvement with the production.
The finished movie paired Daniel Stern’s Marv with Joe Pesci’s Harry, the criminals known as the Wet Bandits. Macaulay Culkin played eight-year-old Kevin McCallister, who protects his family’s home against their attempted break-in.
Columbus Says He Had to Choose Between Stern and Pesci
Columbus said he had envisioned Stern and Pesci together from the outset. When the studio told him it would approve the cost of only one, he chose Pesci and looked for someone else to play the other burglar.
“We did a screen test and they were horrible,” Columbus recalled, according to Entertainment Weekly. He immediately clarified that Pesci had performed well and that his criticism concerned the other actor.
Roebuck challenged that account in a subsequent interview with the outlet. “There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened,” he said, recalling one afternoon together and a dismissal over a perceived lack of chemistry.
Roebuck Says He Was Never Meant to Keep the Role
On a March 2023 episode of What a Character!, Roebuck said he spent about four days on the production. He believed his hiring was a negotiating tactic intended to pressure Stern into accepting less money.
Roebuck admired writer and producer John Hughes, but their encounter left him disappointed. He described receiving the “wettest handshake of my life,” which he took as a sign that Hughes did not want him there, as Page Six reported.
Roebuck also remembered being unable to leave immediately after his dismissal because of a snowstorm. At the time, he was still suggesting other actors who might take over the part.
He said the experience left him frustrated by what he considered a lack of honesty about the circumstances.
Stern Recalled a Scheduling Dispute Before Returning as Marv
Stern described the negotiations in his 2024 memoir, Home and Alone. He had agreed to $300,000 for six weeks of work, but the shooting schedule was extended to eight weeks without a corresponding increase in pay, according to Us Weekly’s coverage of the book.
Stern later described walking away as “one of the stupidest decisions in my showbusiness life.” The production eventually called him back and agreed to honor his original contract and schedule.
Columbus described the subsequent test with Stern and Pesci as an immediate success, according to The Independent. He also said the actor who was dismissed received payment under his contract.
Home Alone opened on November 16, 1990, and earned nearly $500 million worldwide on a reported $18 million budget. Stern and Pesci returned for Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, released in 1992.
Roebuck’s Later Roles Included ‘The Fugitive’ and ‘Lost’
Roebuck went on to play Deputy Marshal Robert Biggs in The Fugitive, the 1993 thriller starring Harrison Ford and Tommy Lee Jones. He returned as Biggs in the 1998 follow-up, U.S. Marshals, and later portrayed Dr. Leslie Arzt on Lost.
Columbus recalled bringing the actor into his office to deliver the dismissal and suggesting that they would work together again. Roebuck remembered a more specific offer of a substantial part in Columbus’s next movie.
The filmmaker went on to direct Mrs. Doubtfire and the first two Harry Potter movies. Both men said the proposed collaboration never happened.
Roebuck praised Stern and Pesci’s performances and said he had no regrets about losing the part. He would still welcome the chance to work with Columbus.




