Judge Judy Sheindlin has spent three decades on television, but she stopped watching her own episodes after realizing she was paying more attention to her appearance than to the cases.
The 83-year-old told People that she initially watched Judge Judy after the syndicated courtroom show began in 1996. She eventually found herself studying her face, neck, hair and camera angles instead of evaluating whether her reasoning from the bench was sound.
“I don’t watch myself on TV,” Sheindlin said. She remembered thinking, “Your face doesn’t look good,” and worrying that becoming aware of which angles she preferred could change the way she naturally positioned herself during future cases.
Sheindlin will nevertheless be revisiting parts of her television career as CBS marks its 30th anniversary with Judge Judy: Unfiltered, Unforgettable on Sept. 22. The retrospective arrives as she prepares to leave the on-camera courtroom when Judy Justice concludes in October.
She Still Laughs at One Particularly ‘Nasty’ Judge Judy Zinger
Sheindlin does occasionally encounter short clips from her courtroom shows on social media, and she told People that some still make her appreciate the decision or response she delivered.
One exchange from 2019 remains a favorite. A woman was suing an ex-boyfriend over $5,000 in loans, and the man had described himself in court papers as her former “boy toy.”
Sheindlin told him that if a dictionary needed a photograph illustrating the term, his picture would appear under the antonym rather than the definition.
“It was so nasty,” she said while laughing about the remark years later.
Sheindlin said lines like that were not prepared in advance. Her quick responses during cases became a defining part of Judge Judy, which ran for 25 seasons from 1996 through 2021. CBS Media Ventures says the series remained the No. 1 courtroom program throughout its original run.
Sheindlin has also maintained that the personality viewers saw was not a character created for television. In her Television Academy oral history, she said her approach on camera largely reflected the way she had handled cases during her years as a New York Family Court judge.
CBS Is Marking Her 30 Years on TV With a Primetime Special
View this post on Instagram
Judge Judy: Unfiltered, Unforgettable traces Sheindlin’s life from her childhood in Brooklyn through her legal career and the television series that made her one of the most recognizable figures in daytime TV.
The 90-minute special includes access to personal archives and previously unseen home movies. Amy Poehler, RuPaul, Samuel L. Jackson, Sherry Lansing and Steven Spielberg are among the celebrities discussing Sheindlin’s television career, alongside relatives, former colleagues and people who appeared before her.
Jackson’s participation has its own connection to the show’s pop-culture history. When he hosted Saturday Night Live in 1998, he appeared in a Judge Judy sketch opposite Cheri Oteri, whose impression of Sheindlin became a recurring part of the series.
The real Sheindlin later appeared alongside Oteri, adding another chapter to the many parodies and references generated during the show’s original run.
CBS will air Judge Judy: Unfiltered, Unforgettable from 8 to 9:30 p.m. ET/PT on Sept. 22. The special will stream live for Paramount+ Premium subscribers and become available on the service the following day.
She Is Leaving the TV Bench but Not Retiring From Work
Sheindlin confirmed during a Sept. 16 appearance on Good Morning America that she is retiring from her on-camera courtroom role after 30 years.
Her son, Judge Adam Levy, has already taken over a television bench of his own. Adam’s Law, which Sheindlin created and executive produces, premiered Sept. 14.
Levy previously served two terms as Putnam County district attorney in New York and has more than 25 years of legal experience. He also appeared as a judge on Tribunal Justice and Justice on Trial before receiving his own syndicated series.
Sheindlin said she still intends to work creatively after leaving the bench. One project is Judyverse, an adult animated series inspired by the AI-generated “Baby Judge Judy” videos that have circulated online. She told the Los Angeles Times that she wants to reclaim the idea from AI and develop the younger animated version of herself as a real character.
She has also discussed another possible format modeled loosely on Andy Rooney’s 60 Minutes commentaries, which would allow her to talk about subjects that irritate her without presiding over a case.
Judy Justice, which began streaming on Prime Video in 2021 after Judge Judy ended, is scheduled to conclude its run on Oct. 22.