A Fake Bank Call Cost Him $19,000. The Driver Who Collected It Didn’t Know It Was a Scam

Leon Raynard Brown and Cecil Silvester Arnold
Image Credit: Highland County Sheriff’s Office.

An Ohio resident handed over $19,000 after callers posing as bank fraud investigators told him his accounts were compromised. The driver sent to collect the cash also believed he was carrying out a legitimate job, according to the Highland County Sheriff’s Office.

Two Florida men have since received prison sentences for their roles in the scam. The sheriff’s office identified them as Leon Raynard Brown and Cecil Silvester Arnold in its November 17, 2026, announcement.

Both men pleaded guilty to aggravated theft from a person in a protected class by deception, a third-degree felony. Their cases were handled in Highland County Common Pleas Court.

The cash collection took place November 27, 2025, at the victim’s home in Brushcreek Township. Deputies began investigating December 1 after he reported the scam.

Callers Said a Federal Agent Would Collect the Money

The callers claimed to represent First State Bank’s fraud department and instructed the resident to withdraw his money for protection. He took cash from banks in Winchester and Hillsboro after being told a federal agent would come to his home to collect it.

A person driving a black Toyota SUV arrived for the pickup. Detectives later identified the driver and determined that he had been hired to transport the money without knowing the delivery was part of a fraud, the sheriff’s office said.

Hotel and Airport Records Helped Identify the Two Defendants

Investigators obtained vehicle video, hotel records, airline records and airport surveillance footage. Those materials helped them identify Brown and Arnold, with assistance from the Milford Police Department, Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport and the Hamilton County Heroin Task Force.

A Highland County grand jury indicted both men. They were extradited from Florida to Ohio to face prosecution.

Court Records Detail a Shared $19,000 Restitution Order

Court docket excerpt recording Arnold’s prison sentence and shared $19,000 restitution obligation with Leon Brown-Harris.
Arnold’s docket records a 12-month sentence, 43 days of jail credit and $19,000 in restitution jointly and severally with Leon Brown-Harris. Document Credit: Highland County Clerk of Courts, case 26CR0127, page 3.

November 5 entries in Brown’s case record and Arnold’s case record list 12-month prison sentences. Both men received credit for 43 days already spent in jail.

The confinement entry in Arnold’s docket specifies $19,000 in restitution, jointly and severally with Brown, whom the court identifies as Leon Brown-Harris. Both men are responsible for that shared obligation.

Call Your Bank Directly Before Withdrawing Cash for a Stranger

The Federal Trade Commission recommends hanging up when an unexpected caller claims your money is at risk, then contacting the bank independently. Use its official app or website, or call the number on your bank card or a recent statement.

The agency also warns against cash handoffs arranged by someone claiming your money needs protection. If a pickup has already been arranged or cash has been collected, contact local police promptly and preserve the caller’s messages, telephone numbers and withdrawal receipts.