Erin Murphy was still in diapers when she appeared in a television commercial with Ronald Reagan. The job came before she became Tabitha Stephens on Bewitched, and before her costar became California’s governor or president.
Murphy, now 62, revisited her early career during the October 31 episode of Front Row Classics: A Hollywood Golden Age Podcast. Speaking with host Brandon Davis on the program published by NPR Illinois, she traced her television work back to infancy.
Her parents had not planned to put their daughters into show business. But outings with Erin and her twin sister, Diane, in a large double stroller repeatedly brought approaches from agents and casting professionals who thought the babies belonged on television.
The family eventually pursued the suggestions, and Murphy began making commercials at 11 months. She described the 1965 Borateem advertisement as her “first major commercial,” according to Entertainment Weekly’s coverage of the interview.
Reagan Pitched Borateem as a Way to Simplify Laundry
In the surviving commercial, Reagan stands outdoors among an assortment of laundry products. He discusses the different promises made by products designed to whiten, brighten, freshen or soften clothes, then presents Borateem as something households can use alongside detergent.
Other shots show a woman handling freshly washed clothes and hanging laundry on a line. Murphy appears separately on a blanket, moving among toys. Reagan returns to the screen holding the product’s boxes as he finishes the sales pitch.
Murphy had already made an advertisement for Folgers coffee. A WOBM-AM account of her 2014 interview with Joel Markel identified that commercial, in which she played a baby boy, as her first job, followed by the Reagan spot.
She has since shared the Borateem footage on Facebook for fans interested in that early credit. “Probably the most famous person I ever worked with!” she wrote in the caption accompanying the clip.
Erin and Diane Won Tabitha’s Role Through a Playroom Audition
The twins joined Bewitched in 1966 as its producers prepared to expand Tabitha’s part in the story. The sitcom had debuted in black and white in 1964, and its third season would bring the transition to color. Casting twins allowed two children to share the role around limits on young performers’ working hours.
In an archived interview with The Bewitched & Elizabeth Montgomery Site, Murphy explained that her mother had described the audition to her. Producer William Asher and other members of the team watched children playing with toys. Several callbacks followed before the sisters were selected.
Erin eventually performed most of Tabitha’s scenes. During her May appearance on Billy Corgan’s The Magnificent Others, she explained that she and Diane were fraternal twins whose appearances differed. Erin was used primarily for shots showing her face, while Diane appeared from behind or farther away.
Murphy said she enjoyed the studio lights and was comfortable following directions about where to sit or what to say. Her parents took turns accompanying her, sometimes waiting in the dressing room while she worked with the director and her television family.
Reagan’s Advertising Work Overlapped With His Move Into Politics
Reagan’s screen career already included Knute Rockne, All American and Bedtime for Bonzo, along with hosting General Electric Theater. He also hosted Death Valley Days, a Western anthology sponsored by U.S. Borax.
The Autry Museum of the American West holds production records showing how that advertising work intersected with his political ambitions. A contract-renewal memo weighed his effectiveness as a salesman against concerns about his availability and the possible consequences of a political campaign. The producers renewed his contract.
His nationally televised speech supporting Barry Goldwater had already aired in October 1964. Reagan announced his campaign for governor in January 1966 and won that November, taking office the following January, as the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library records.
After two terms leading California, he won the presidency in 1980. His first presidential inauguration took place on January 20, 1981, approximately 16 years after the commercial in which Murphy appeared.
Murphy Grew Up Around Bewitched’s Adult Cast and Crew
Murphy spent six seasons playing Tabitha, working alongside Elizabeth Montgomery as Samantha and Dick York as the original Darrin. The Television Academy describes the sitcom’s central conflict as Samantha’s effort to combine her magical abilities with an ordinary suburban marriage to a mortal.
Tabitha inherited her mother’s powers, allowing the series to explore what happened when a young child could change the world around her. Murphy remained with the show through its conclusion in March 1972, when she was seven.
When new scripts arrived, Murphy highlighted her lines and became excited if Tabitha had a large part. She told Corgan that she joined the cast’s Monday table reads, where tea, sugar cubes and doughnuts accompanied the week’s dialogue.
Some of her clearest memories involve the animals brought onto the set. She told Corgan that she remembered touching a baby elephant outside the stage doors and spending time beside a chimpanzee. She has also spoken about enjoying episodes with other children, since so much of her working day was spent with adults.
Murphy’s Friendship With Elizabeth Montgomery Extended Beyond Filming
Montgomery became an important figure in Murphy’s childhood. In the archived interview, Murphy described her as a second mother and said she called her “Mantha Mommy.” The two families also spent time together away from the studio.
Murphy recalled being delighted when Montgomery’s daughter Rebecca was born on Murphy’s own birthday. She visited the family after the baby’s arrival and later regarded Rebecca as the younger sister she had always wanted, joining in activities such as miniature golf.
Trips to the movies were another shared memory. Murphy said her mother and Montgomery would sit in the balcony while the children watched below, sometimes tossing popcorn down toward them.




