Jared Padalecki Tears Up Recalling How ‘Gilmore Girls’ Rival Milo Ventimiglia Took Him ‘Under His Wing’

Milo Ventimiglia and Jared Padalecki
Image Credit: DFree / Shutterstock. Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.

Jared Padalecki spent his breaks on Gilmore Girls reading alone in his trailer. He would pick up a book and stay there until a crew member knocked to call him back to set. What brought him to tears in a new documentary was remembering how Milo Ventimiglia changed that routine.

Ventimiglia joined the show in 2001 as Jess Mariano, Luke Danes’ bookish nephew. Padalecki had played Dean Forester since the pilot. He figured Jess was there to take Dean’s place as the boyfriend of Rory Gilmore, played by Alexis Bledel.

Padalecki was still a teenager. Even with a role on a television series, he wondered whether he could make a living as an actor. Ventimiglia was five years older and someone Padalecki came to count on at work.

Years later, directors Meghna Balakumar and Kevin Konrad Hanna interviewed Padalecki at his home in Texas for Drink Coffee, Talk Fast: A Documentary About Gilmore Girls. By then, he had spent 15 seasons playing Sam Winchester on Supernatural.

What Milo Ventimiglia Asked Between Scenes

Ventimiglia suggested they work out together at a gym. If Padalecki felt like getting outside, they could take a walk. And if all he wanted to do was sit and talk, Ventimiglia was up for that, too.

“Milo took me under his wing and was kind to me every step of the way,” Padalecki recalled in the film, according to Entertainment Weekly. He paused to wipe his eyes, then found a way to make a joke about crying on camera. “What is that? I’m not even acting.”

Padalecki Had a Backup Plan the Week He Auditioned for Dean

At 17, Padalecki had given himself until the end of the week to book steady work. If nothing came through, he planned to drive back to Austin and attend the University of Texas. The producers of Gilmore Girls had already cast two other actors as Dean by the time his manager called about an audition.

In a clip shared with PEOPLE, casting directors Jami Rudofsky and Mara Casey recalled going to find series creator Amy Sherman-Palladino so she could see him. While they were gone, Padalecki took a walk around the Warner Bros. lot. He figured it might be his only chance to see the place. Sherman-Palladino saw his audition and agreed they had found Dean.

Jimmy Fallon Spotted a Vote for Dean on Ventimiglia’s Wall

Fans spent years asking whether Rory belonged with Dean or Jess. During a remote appearance on The Tonight Show in April 2021, Jimmy Fallon spotted Ventimiglia’s answer on the wall behind him. Ventimiglia had made a little sign declaring his love for Dean, then stuck it on his framed Emmy nomination certificate.

Padalecki answered on Instagram with a handmade sign for Jess. For his version of the photo, he posed with a “Best Body” trophy his wife, Genevieve, had bought him in Hollywood. As Entertainment Tonight reported, Padalecki signed off by telling Ventimiglia he missed him and was proud of him.

How the Filmmakers Reached Padalecki Through Another Costar

Chad Michael Murray helped arrange Padalecki’s interview. In an October 2025 interview with PEOPLE, Balakumar recalled visiting Murray at his house when he offered to text his old castmate. She soon found herself in a group chat with both actors, the kind of development she said her 12-year-old self would have loved.

The independent film grew out of a Kickstarter campaign launched in September 2025, just before the show’s 25th anniversary. Kelly Bishop, Keiko Agena and Sally Struthers sat for interviews. Scott Patterson, who played Luke, also served as an executive producer. The film reached Apple TV and other digital rental services on November 17, 2026.

Ventimiglia is taking part in a separate HBO Max documentary with Lauren Graham and Sherman-Palladino. Asked by Us Weekly on November 2 what he remembered from making the series, he had his own answer about what happened between takes. “Hanging out with Jared Padalecki, being with Alexis,” he said.