Jennifer Lopez Bursts Out Laughing at Fan’s ‘Six More Fingers’ Joke About Her Four Divorces

Jennifer Lopez
Image Credit: MLM IMAGES Los Angeles / Shutterstock.

Jennifer Lopez was talking about her four divorces when a woman in the audience offered an unexpected reason to keep counting. The singer stopped, pointed toward the fan and laughed so hard that she began stamping her feet onstage.

The exchange took place Sunday, November 15, during a screening and conversation at New York’s 92NY. Lopez, 57, appeared with actress Rachel Zegler to discuss her upcoming concert special, The JLO Show: Live in Las Vegas.

After Lopez acknowledged how many times she had been divorced, the audience member shouted, “You have six more fingers!” The singer immediately played along, while a recording of the moment later circulated on Instagram.

The discussion was part of a wider look at how Lopez’s life has shaped her performances. Her new concert film combines music with personal storytelling, and she has spoken this year about learning to feel comfortable on her own after her marriage to Ben Affleck ended.

Jennifer Lopez Turns the Fan’s Divorce Joke Into a T-Shirt Idea

“Yes, I do!” Lopez responded to the woman, clearly enjoying the interruption. According to Entertainment Weekly, she threw her head back in amusement and called the remark the funniest thing she had ever heard.

She and Zegler then considered another use for the line: putting it on a T-shirt. Lopez repeated the phrase as she imagined turning an audience member’s spontaneous observation into something she could wear.

Comedian Nikki Glaser had a different suggestion after seeing the fan-shared Instagram clip. She proposed “6 More Fingers” as the title of Lopez’s next single. Other viewers praised the audience member for finding an affectionate way to joke about a subject that has followed the singer through much of her career.

The exchange nevertheless left a more serious question open. Once the laughter settled, Lopez acknowledged that she wasn’t sure she had another marriage in her. Enjoying the joke did not mean she was making plans for a fifth wedding.

Lopez’s Four Marriages Include a Second Chance With Ben Affleck

Lopez’s marital history stretches back nearly three decades. She married Ojani Noa in 1997, and their divorce followed in 1998. Her second marriage, to dancer Cris Judd, began in 2001 and ended in 2003.

She married Marc Anthony in 2004. The singers share twins Max and Emme, now 18, and their divorce was finalized in 2014. Parenthood remained an important part of Lopez’s life through the relationships and career changes that followed.

Her marriage to Affleck came after a reunion that attracted considerable attention. They had first been engaged in the early 2000s before separating, then rekindled their relationship years later and married in July 2022. Lopez filed for divorce in August 2024.

The timing of that divorce involves two separate dates. A judge approved their settlement on January 6, 2025, but the divorce took effect on February 21, according to The Associated Press. The former couple had reached an agreement through mediation, and neither was required to pay the other spousal support.

Lopez Took a Year Off to Focus on Herself and Her Children

During a March 11 interview with Juju Chang on Good Morning America, Lopez explained why she had stepped back from work after the breakup. She said she took a year off, canceled tours and made being home with her children the priority.

She wanted to face what had happened without using another project or another relationship as a distraction. That meant spending time examining her own choices and trying to understand herself, rather than immediately looking for someone else to blame.

By the time of the interview, she described herself as being in her “happy era.” She spoke about developing greater trust in herself and feeling less pressure to prove things to other people. Being alone, something she had once feared, had begun to feel good.

Asked whether she was dating at that time, Lopez said she wasn’t. She also spoke enthusiastically about returning to the stage with a production that incorporated Broadway influences and new arrangements of familiar songs. The residency gave her an opportunity to perform with an orchestra onstage, something she said she had long wanted to do.

The JLO Show Brings Her Las Vegas Residency to Television

The concert film captures the March 28 final performance of Lopez’s 12-show residency at The Colosseum at Caesars Palace. A vocal ensemble and 16 dancers join her for a production that moves between pop performances and stories about her journey from the Bronx to international fame.

During the 92NY conversation, Lopez explained that she also wanted to preserve that story for her family. According to PEOPLE, she imagined her children and future grandchildren being able to watch the show and understand who she was, what inspired her and what she had overcome.

The set includes “Waiting for Tonight,” “Jenny from the Block,” “Love Don’t Cost a Thing,” “On the Floor” and “Let’s Get Loud.” Broadway selections and tributes to earlier Las Vegas entertainers appear alongside her own catalog.

Paramount+ confirms that the special will air on CBS on Thanksgiving, November 26, from 8 to 10 p.m. ET/PT. Paramount+ Premium subscribers can stream the CBS broadcast live. An extended version containing additional performance footage will also become available to subscribers on all Paramount+ plans that evening at 8 p.m. ET.