Pete Davidson Turns Comedy Into Controversy After Charlie Kirk Joke Sparks Raw Reaction

Screenshot from entertainmentweekly/Instagram. Used under fair use for editorial commentary
by

Pete Davidson has never exactly played it safe. The 32-year-old Staten Island native built his entire career on dragging the unspeakable into the spotlight, weaponizing his own grief, his mental health struggles, and his borderline catastrophic personal life into punchlines that audiences couldn’t help but laugh at, even when they probably shouldn’t.

He lost his firefighter father on September 11, 2001, and turned that trauma into some of the most searingly honest comedy of his generation. That backstory has always been the invisible armor he wears onstage, the thing that says, “I have earned this.”

But on Sunday night, standing at the roast podium at the Kia Forum in Inglewood, California, during Netflix’s live “Roast of Kevin Hart,” Davidson reached for a joke that landed with a thud so loud the entire room felt it.

Eight months to the day after Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk was shot and killed on stage at Utah Valley University, Pete Davidson made Kirk the punchline. And not even the main punchline. A side one. A throwaway. That’s almost what made it worse.

What Actually Happened Onstage

The roast, which streamed live on Netflix on Sunday, May 10, as part of the Netflix Is a Joke Festival, was a three-hour celebrity pile-on featuring Dwayne Johnson, Tom Brady, Chelsea Handler, Shane Gillis, Jeff Ross, and Sheryl Underwood, among others.

Kevin Hart, 46, sat in the hot seat as everyone took their swings. Davidson’s slot was doing what roast comics always do: using the room itself as target practice. His focus landed on fellow comedian Tony Hinchcliffe, the host of the popular weekly stand-up podcast “Kill Tony.”

Davidson opened his Hinchcliffe bit without mercy: “Tony Hinchcliffe is here, looking like both a child molester and the doll they give the child to show where he touched them.”

That line got laughs. Then came the one that didn’t. “Tony reminds me of Charlie Kirk, in that he’s definitely been on camera letting a guy unload in his throat.”

The reference was unmistakable. Kirk was assassinated on September 10, 2025, while delivering a speech at Utah Valley University. The bullet struck his neck. The shooting was captured on video and went viral almost immediately.

Davidson then doubled down with a wordplay move on Hinchcliffe’s podcast title: “Oh, you don’t know me? Yeah, ‘Kill Tony.’ Please, someone f—ing kill Tony.” The audience’s reaction told its own story.

There were groans, scattered gasps, and an audible discomfort that roast crowds, who typically cheer the most savage lines, almost never produce.

A Close Friend Speaks Out

The morning after the special aired, Andrew Kolvet, a producer with Turning Point USA and someone who knew Charlie Kirk personally, addressed the moment directly on “The Charlie Kirk Show” podcast.

 

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

A post shared by TMZ (@tmz_tv)

His response was measured but unmistakably raw. “I would make two observations,” Kolvet said. “One, this is about somebody who was murdered in really the most grotesque public way imaginable, and he happens to be our close friend.” He didn’t stop there.

“Two, you know, I just don’t think it was funny. And when I saw the clip this morning, my instinct was just to cringe. Because it was kind of in a similar vein that people in the audience did that groan.” Kolvet made clear he wasn’t issuing a blanket condemnation of comedy as an art form.

He noted that when South Park once roasted Charlie Kirk during his lifetime, Kirk’s reaction was enthusiasm, not offense, reportedly saying, “This is amazing,” and encouraging them to push harder.

The distinction Kolvet was drawing was not between left and right. It was between punching a living man who can punch back and making the manner of his murder the mechanism of a joke, eight months after his family watched it happen in real time.

The Bigger Picture Nobody Is Talking About

Here is the part that tends to get lost when the internet breaks into its predictable two-sided war over a celebrity controversy: Pete Davidson is not some edgelord trying to shock for shock’s sake alone.

He is also a man who has publicly and repeatedly spoken about the trauma of losing a parent to a public, violent death. His father, Scott Davidson, was a New York City firefighter who died in the September 11 attacks.

Pete was seven years old. He has built an entire comedic identity around survival and dark humor as a coping mechanism. That history makes Sunday’s moment genuinely complicated in a way that the hot takes being shared across X don’t fully capture.

Because if anyone in that room could have understood the weight of joking about a man being shot on camera, it was Davidson. That’s not an accusation. It’s an irony worth sitting with.

It also matters that Netflix, as a streaming platform, operates entirely outside the FCC’s jurisdiction. That detail is not small. When Jimmy Kimmel made comments about Kirk’s assassination on ABC last fall, the FCC chairman threatened Disney’s broadcast licenses.

ABC suspended Kimmel’s show for nearly a week. The political and regulatory machinery that came crashing down on a broadcast network had no reach over Sunday night’s Netflix special.

Davidson’s joke aired unedited, uninterrupted, and with no institutional consequence whatsoever. Whether that’s a feature or a bug of the streaming age depends entirely on where you stand.

Social Media, Split Right Down the Middle

The response online was immediate and exactly as divided as anyone would expect. On one side: “Anything goes in comedy, but this ain’t it. Charlie was murdered just 8 months ago and we wonder why people have become so desensitized to political violence.”

On the other hand, “By design the jokes at roasts are extremely brutal, and no person or group is safe from mockery. If you don’t like that, which I 100% get, don’t watch it.” Both of those takes are correct, depending on what question you’re actually answering.

If the question is “does roast comedy have the right to go there?” the answer is yes, legally and historically. If the question is “did the joke land?” the audience’s groan answered that one in real time.

Even some defenders of Davidson’s right to make the joke acknowledged it didn’t work on a purely technical level. One X user put it plainly: “Nothing should be off limits to comedians, but it wasn’t even funny.

Roasts are supposed to be shocking but also funny. Not just shockingly deranged.” That might be the most honest assessment of all.

The Angle Nobody Wants To Hear

Here is the argument that won’t be popular on either side: Pete Davidson may have done something genuinely useful by accident. Comedy, at its best, forces a culture to look at the things it is most uncomfortable examining.

Charlie Kirk’s assassination was a genuinely traumatic national event, regardless of political affiliation. The video of it spread across every platform. Millions of people saw it, processed it, and never really talked about what they were feeling in a shared public space, because the political stakes around Kirk made honest conversation nearly impossible.

A bad joke at a roast, one that bombs in the room and gets groaned at by a live crowd, is actually a form of cultural reckoning. It says: we are now in a place where a mainstream comedian felt this was territory to enter, and the room collectively said not yet.

That collective “not yet” is information. It’s a boundary being drawn in real time, by an audience, without the FCC, without government pressure, and without a network executive making the call. That’s nothing.

Davidson wrapped up his set on a surprisingly tender note. “I love you very much,” he told Kevin Hart. “You’ve always been super nice to me. You’re a very hardworking person, and when it’s all said and done, in the comedy world, it’s most important to be remembered.”

The crowd gave him that. The Charlie Kirk moment, though, is the one they walked out talking about. And talking is probably where this was always supposed to land.

Previous

Colbert’s Late Night Farewell With the Strike Force Five Turns Explosive as Trump, Melania and Network Pressure Take Over the Room