Christina Ricci Says Cher Still ‘Holds a Grudge’ Over a Voicemail She Never Returned at 19

Christina Ricc
Image Credit: Featureflash Photo Agency / Shutterstock.

Christina Ricci never returned an apologetic voicemail from Cher when she was 19. Nearly three decades later, she believes that unanswered message is why her former Mermaids costar remains distant.

The actress, 46, discussed their relationship during the November 17th After Show of Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen. Asked whether they were still in touch, she replied, “Unfortunately, she’s still mad at me. She holds a grudge.”

Ricci said she has attempted to contact the singer since then, only to receive “radio silence.” Cohen appeared surprised by the admission and asked what had happened between them.

E! News said in its November 18th coverage that it had contacted a representative for Cher, 80, for comment but had not heard back. The singer has not publicly confirmed Ricci’s explanation for their lost contact.

Christina Ricci Explains the Magazine Interview Behind Cher’s Voicemail

During the Bravo segment, Ricci recalled a magazine feature about her for which a journalist had interviewed Cher. She initially named Rolling Stone, then wondered whether the publication had actually been Premiere. She remembered finding the resulting comments unflattering, although she did not repeat what Cher had supposedly said.

In the voicemail, according to Ricci, Cher explained that journalists had misrepresented her words and apologized for how the interview had turned out.

Looking back as an adult, Ricci said she understood why her failure to respond could have seemed rude. She could imagine the frustration of trying to clear up a misunderstanding with a younger colleague and receiving no acknowledgment.

Turning toward the camera, Ricci addressed Cher directly: “Love you, Cher, I love you so much.”

Ricci Previously Shared Her Regret About Losing Touch With Cher

Ricci had acknowledged the distance between them long before this week’s appearance. In a June 2018 interview with The A.V. Club, she said they had stayed in contact for about ten years after making Mermaids. She regretted that they had lost touch, but did not mention the unanswered message during that conversation.

The same interview included her memories of landing the film, her feature debut. Ricci traveled from her suburban childhood home to Boston to audition with Cher, flew back to New Jersey that evening and learned late that night that she had won the role.

Directed by Richard Benjamin, the 1990 film cast Cher as Rachel Flax, an unconventional single mother raising two daughters. Winona Ryder played Charlotte, the older daughter, while Ricci portrayed Kate, whose enthusiasm for swimming was a defining part of the character.

Ricci and Ryder also joined Cher in the video for “The Shoop Shoop Song (It’s in His Kiss),” featured on the movie’s soundtrack. Ricci remembered being surprised by how late the shoot continued. Afterward, Cher took her to her Malibu home for a sleepover that Ricci described as a pajama party.

Cher Paused Her Preparation to Explain Acting to Young Ricci

During a November 13th, 2024, appearance on The Drew Barrymore Show, Ricci recalled how patiently Cher answered her questions on set. As PEOPLE documented, one exchange happened while the singer was preparing to cry in a scene.

Cher had headphones on and was getting ready for the emotional performance when Ricci asked how she made herself cry. Instead of turning the young actress away, she removed the headphones and explained her process.

Ricci told Barrymore that she appreciated the gesture even more as an experienced performer. Preparing for a difficult scene can require concentration and privacy, yet Cher had made time for a child’s question. “Honestly, every good thing you believe about Cher is true,” she said.

Ricci Learned About Boundaries While Spending Time in Cher’s Trailer

On WTF with Marc Maron in August 2022, Ricci recalled Cher explaining production decisions to her, including a change of director. According to Audacy’s coverage of the podcast, Cher sometimes let her sit quietly at the back of her trailer during meetings so she could understand what was happening.

In Demi Lovato’s 2024 documentary Child Star, Ricci said an inexperienced child might assume tensions between adults were somehow her fault. As Entertainment Weekly reported, she credited Cher with helping prevent that insecurity and recalled learning from women who established boundaries about how they would be treated.

The trailer held less serious attractions, too. Ricci remembered hiding there to avoid tutoring and eating See’s Candies chocolate lollipops, a favorite of her famous costar.