Former Miss North Carolina USA Brittany Boltinhouse says pageant officials publicly attributed an apology to her that she never approved after criticism of her past social media posts.
In new court papers reported by TMZ on November 19, the 27-year-old is asking a judge to reject an attempt to dismiss her defamation lawsuit against Miss USA CEO Thom Brodeur and other pageant defendants.
Boltinhouse acknowledges using a racial slur in posts from 2017 and 2019. Her lawyers characterize the language as slang and dispute that it establishes racist intent.
Her complaint acknowledges the pageant organization’s authority to remove a titleholder. She is not asking the court to reinstate her as Miss North Carolina USA.
She Says Pageant Organizers Wrote the Apology
Brodeur publicly said he had seen a statement from Boltinhouse containing “ownership, accountability and apology.” Her September amended complaint, published by Courthouse News Service, identifies state pageant operator A Blaize Productions as the author and co-director Nic Blaize as the person who emailed her the draft.
The proposed statement would have had Boltinhouse accept responsibility for past words and actions, apologize to people who were hurt and thank the organizers for the opportunity to hold the title. She says she had no role in writing the document and never signed or published it.
Her Reign Ended Weeks After Her Crowning
View this post on Instagram
Boltinhouse won the 2026 state title in late June, qualifying to represent North Carolina at the national competition in Miami. Her removal was announced on August 5, less than three weeks before the Miss USA pageant was scheduled to begin.
Brodeur’s explanation emphasized that titleholders were expected to uphold the organization’s standards. He said it prohibited racism, homophobia, transphobia and language that demeaned others, and described concerns about conduct over an extended period without identifying specific incidents.
First runner-up Myla Hadley assumed the crown. Brodeur said she had the organization’s confidence and support ahead of the national competition.
Pageant Officials Argue Their Remarks Were Legally Protected
In a motion dated November 2, Brodeur’s legal team argued that the challenged comments were either opinions or true factual statements, according to WRAL. The defense contends that Boltinhouse has not stated a legally sufficient defamation claim.
PEOPLE reported that the motion also argued Brodeur had not explicitly called her racist, homophobic or transphobic. The defendants maintain that her own complaint supports the truth of their statements.
Her attorneys counter that describing someone’s conduct and claiming that person admitted wrongdoing are different assertions. They argue that whether she authorized an apology is a factual question, rather than simply an expression of opinion.
She Says Her Beliefs Influenced Her Removal
In an August 7 interview with Carolina Journal, Boltinhouse said she believed being a conservative Christian woman contributed to the decision.
Her lawsuit cites recorded conversations with state pageant officials that she says reflected concern about public backlash over her views. It also alleges that A Blaize Productions feared risking its franchise status if she remained the titleholder.
A Blaize Productions rejected the claim that her beliefs drove the decision in an August 12 statement to ABC News. The company said it had repeatedly explained the factors behind its decision and had distinguished her personal political and religious beliefs from the conduct and material it questioned.
Her Lawsuit Seeks Damages for Claimed Career Losses
Boltinhouse originally filed suit in August in Duplin County Superior Court in North Carolina. The defendants include Brodeur, companies associated with Miss USA, A Blaize Productions and state pageant officials Ariana Blaize and Nic Blaize.
The existing case moved to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina on October 26, according to the docket published by Justia. Her lawyers subsequently requested that it return to state court.
She seeks compensatory and punitive damages for harm she attributes to the defendants’ public statements. Her claimed losses include sponsorships, endorsements, appearances and other professional opportunities, along with emotional distress and the expense of responding to the disputed publicity.




