Mo Brings Plenty’s loss of his nephew Cole helped shape a new Marshals storyline. “It was a struggle for me to have to relive a lot of that,” the actor told PEOPLE.
Cole had followed his uncle into the Yellowstone franchise, playing Pete Plenty Clouds in the prequel 1923. He was 27 when he died.
The CBS spinoff’s November 15 episode, “Roughstock,” follows Mo and Kayce Dutton as they search for Mo’s missing nephew, Troy. Brings Plenty, 57, has played the character of Mo since Yellowstone began in 2018.
Showrunner Spencer Hudnut initially imagined the mystery involving a former teammate of Kayce’s. He consulted Brings Plenty, and the actor and his brother Joe, Cole’s father, shared their experiences with the writers, according to TV Insider.
Brings Plenty Relied on Familiar Faces While Filming
Luke Grimes and Gil Birmingham already knew what had happened to the Brings Plenty family. Mo said he could turn to both actors for support, describing them as “brothers in real life.” Joe was also on set during the episode’s production.
Will Strongheart, who plays Troy, knew Cole personally and understood what the family had been through, Brings Plenty told Decider. He had known Strongheart for years and welcomed his involvement in the story.
During filming, they shared funny memories of Cole and remembered how readily he helped others. Brings Plenty said he hoped the episode would speak to other Indigenous families experiencing similar losses.
Kayce Challenges the Sheriff’s Explanation for Troy’s Death
After discovering Troy’s body on a mountain, Kayce faces a sheriff who treats the death as a suicide. Kayce continues working beyond his jurisdiction as a U.S. marshal and asks colleague Andrea, played by Ash Santos, to find a way for the team to take the case.
The trail leads to two poachers who spent time with Troy before he died. Their account helps establish that another man pushed him from a cliff during an argument. The episode leaves that man’s identity unresolved.
Hudnut said Troy’s case would continue later in the season and could connect to a larger conspiracy. New episodes of Marshals air Sundays on CBS and stream the following day on Paramount+, according to Entertainment Weekly.
The Farewell Ceremony Drew on Brings Plenty’s Own Grief
The production had previously welcomed Cole’s relatives for a memorial scene honoring Kayce’s late wife, Monica. As Brings Plenty explained to USA TODAY, that gathering also became a personal remembrance of his nephew. The earlier episode, “Out of the Shadows,” aired on the second anniversary of the day Cole was found.
Troy’s farewell includes a version of the wiping of the tears ceremony. Brings Plenty described it as a way of helping families mourn while remembering the person’s life and what they had done for others.
In the episode’s final private mourning scene, Mo sees a white horse. Brings Plenty told TVLine that it represents the other side and his character’s belief that Troy has reached his ancestors. He described having that same belief about Cole.
At Cole’s funeral, a relative had asked the family to look south, where Brings Plenty remembered seeing an eagle followed by a red-tailed hawk flying low. He recalled feeling reassured by the sight as his family said goodbye.
Cole’s Family Still Questions the Findings in His Death
Cole was last seen March 31, 2024, and found dead in rural Johnson County, Kansas, on April 5. Lawrence police had identified him as a suspect in a domestic violence investigation.
Mo has publicly challenged how thoroughly his nephew’s death was investigated. The Johnson County Sheriff’s Office announced on April 10 that investigators found no indication of foul play. In responses to his criticism earlier this year, authorities said they had conducted a thorough investigation and shared the findings with the family.
A judge sealed the autopsy report and law enforcement case files at the family’s request, with KSHB reporting the order in April 2024. The agencies have cited that order in explaining why they cannot publicly disclose further investigative details. Cole’s cause of death has not been publicly released.




