The Shards ended its first season without telling viewers who the Trawler is, but one of the finale’s most suspicious moments was never planned on the page.
Shortly before Terry Schaffer is pushed from a balcony during his Halloween party, his assistant Steven Reinhardt, played by Jordan Roth, shares a prolonged silent look with Robert Mallory, played by Homer Gere. Speaking with Entertainment Weekly after the Sept. 9 finale, Roth revealed that the exchange was unscripted.
No dialogue passes between Steven and Robert. Instead, the finished episode holds on the two men long enough for an ordinary glance to take on considerably more weight, raising a new question about whether they know more about each other than viewers have been told.
Roth is not answering that question yet. He does, however, believe the final edit establishes that “something is going on there” and that the characters have some kind of history, while stopping well short of connecting either man to Terry’s fall.
The Steven-Robert Stare Came From an Unscripted Moment
Roth explained that directors on The Shards often kept cameras running after the scripted dialogue had ended, allowing actors to remain inside a scene and react without knowing whether those small moments would survive the edit.
He said some of the show’s more intriguing details emerged from those stretches, when eyes moved, looks lingered and suspicions could develop without dialogue. The Steven-Robert exchange was one of them.
What made the moment stand out to Roth was that the characters had occupied the same spaces earlier in the season without meaningfully engaging. In the finale, their sudden attention to each other was given much greater weight.
Roth noticed that in the finished cut as well. He said the stare was held and given enough importance to establish that “there is history” between Steven and Robert, but he did not reveal what that history might involve.
Terry is pushed from the balcony only moments later. The episode never shows who pushed him, however, so the stare creates another line of suspicion rather than solving the mystery.
Steven’s Final Smirk Gives Viewers Another Reason to Watch Him
Steven gets another small but conspicuous reaction near the end of the finale, when investigators gather the central characters and reveal that evidence may connect several of the season’s crimes to somebody in the room. While most of the group appears alarmed, Steven smirks.
Roth told EW that he does not read the expression simply as Steven enjoying the possibility that he might be suspected. He sees the character as someone who is constantly watching the people around him, collecting information and thinking about how it might become useful later.
That interpretation had already surfaced earlier in the season. During Episode 4 of FX’s official The Shards podcast, Roth said Steven would begin to “pull the strings and turn the screws” once the season moved into its back half. The finale leaves open what those manipulations ultimately amount to. Roth says Steven is capable of almost anything.
The Finale Leaves Both Terry’s Attacker and the Trawler Unidentified
View this post on Instagram
Terry survives the balcony fall through the end of the episode, although his condition is grave. Bret says he is on life support and could still die.
The larger mystery ends in the same state of uncertainty. PEOPLE’s finale breakdown notes that investigators gather Bret, Robert, Susan, Thom, Debbie, Liz, Steven and Ryan after finding evidence connected to the deaths of Katherine Latchford and Matt Kellner and the kidnapping of Rhonda Fox.
Police tell the group that they believe those crimes are connected and that the person responsible is among them. Bret remains convinced Robert is the Trawler, but the finale also gives viewers new reasons to question Bret’s reliability, including Robert’s challenge to what Bret has said about his own parents.
The screen cuts to black before investigators identify anyone, leaving Steven and Robert’s silent exchange as one more unresolved detail inside a mystery that has deliberately widened.
FX Hasn’t Renewed Season 2 Yet, but the Writers Are Already Working
A second season has not been formally ordered by FX as of Sept. 10, but the creative team is no longer speaking about a continuation only in hypothetical terms.
Executive producer Brad Simpson told TV Insider after the finale that the writers are already working on what would become the next season. He also revealed that an entire Palm Springs episode had been written for Season 1 but could not fit into the nine-episode order and remains available to explore later.
Ryan Murphy had already made clear before the finale that the plan was larger than a single season. He said Bret Easton Ellis never wanted the novel treated strictly as a limited series and had imagined it as roughly a three-season drama, potentially longer.
Roth is thinking ahead too. He told EW that there are still many directions he wants to take Steven and believes viewers have only begun to see how much the character can manipulate the people around him.