Why Jake Paul Was Never Beating Anthony Joshua (And Why the Circus Had To End)

Image Credit: YouTube

If you are surprised by what happened in Miami last night (Friday, Dec. 19), you haven’t been paying attention

We just watched a 6’6” former unified heavyweight champion dismantle a YouTuber in six rounds. It wasn’t a “robbery.” It wasn’t a “lucky punch.” It was physics, experience, and elite-level skill all culminating in a beatdown that shouldn’t have surprised anyone. But to fully understand why this result was written in the stars long before the opening bell, you have to look past the marketing and focus on the cold, hard reality of Jake Paul’s resume.

Let’s do a quick audit of the road that led here.

Before last night, Jake Paul built a lucrative career on carefully calculated risks. He knocked out Ben Askren (a wrestler with bad hips) and Nate Robinson (a basketball player). He decisioned Anderson Silva (47 years old) and Mike Tyson (58 years old). Even when he fought tough guys like Mike Perry or Nate Diaz, they were significantly smaller men giving up massive weight advantages.

The only time he stepped in with a “real” boxer his own age was Tommy Fury. And he lost.

So, what was he thinking signing the contract with Anthony Joshua?

AJ isn’t a retired MMA fighter looking for a paycheck. He is a 245lb active heavyweight who has been in the ring with Usyk and Klitschko. The moment the weigh-in happened, the delusion should have ended. Joshua outweighed him by about 27 pounds at the weigh-in and towered over him by five inches.

That broken jaw Jake is nursing today isn’t a badge of honor; it’s a receipt for hubris.

But don’t feel too bad for him, because he just pulled off the heist of the century.

While boxing fans are celebrating the end of the “Problem Child” era, Jake Paul is laughing all the way to the bank. Some reports and industry estimates suggested the fight could generate a total purse in the neighborhood of $184 million to $200 million. Even if he got the short end of that stick, Jake Paul likely cleared more money in 18 minutes of getting beat up than most legitimate champions make in a lifetime.

He didn’t fight Anthony Joshua to win. He fought him to cash out. And in that sense, he remains undefeated.

The question now is: Where does he go from here?

Anthony Joshua is officially back. His post-fight callout of Tyson Fury (“Put down your Twitter fingers”) gave me chills. That’s the fight we actually want to see in 2026. But for Jake, the road is much rockier.

He can’t go back to fighting retired UFC stars; the gimmick is dead. He clearly can’t hang with elite heavyweights. Unless he wants to keep getting concussed for cash, this should be the series finale.

I’ve seen people celebrating this as a victory for “real boxing,” but I disagree.

This fight shouldn’t have been sanctioned. Watching a professional heavyweight tee off on an influencer for six rounds wasn’t sport; it was a mismatch dressed up as entertainment. Jake Paul proved he has a chin, I’ll give him that. But Anthony Joshua proved that there are levels to this game that no amount of marketing (or Netflix money) can bridge.