A New York man faces 56 criminal charges after police accused him of stealing credit cards and personal information from lockers at four Nassau County fitness facilities. Investigators say Russell Portnoy, 34, of Hempstead, then used the stolen cards to make purchases.
The Nassau County Police Department listed nine incidents between September 17 and November 5, 2026. Six occurred at the same LA Fitness in Garden City.
Third Squad detectives arrested Portnoy without incident at approximately 11:30 p.m. on November 16. Police announced the arrest the following day, identifying locations in Garden City, New Hyde Park and Carle Place.
Portnoy pleaded not guilty at his November 17 arraignment, according to Nassau District Court records. A judge also issued a temporary order of protection.
Six Alleged Thefts Occurred at One LA Fitness
The first five incidents listed by police occurred September 17, 18, 20, 22 and 23 at LA Fitness, 711 Stewart Avenue in Garden City. Detectives allege Portnoy returned to that location on October 3.
The remaining allegations involve three other businesses. Police listed an October 15 incident at LA Fitness, 1111 Marcus Avenue in New Hyde Park, followed by an October 30 incident at Metro Physical & Aquatic Therapy, 800 East Gate Boulevard in Garden City.
The final incident in the announcement occurred November 5 at Planet Fitness, 177A Old Country Road in Carle Place. Across the cases, investigators described the same alleged conduct: taking cards and identifying information from lockers before leaving and making purchases.
Charges Include 17 Counts of Identity Theft

The court’s charge listing includes 11 counts of second-degree identity theft and six counts of third-degree identity theft. Portnoy also faces eight counts of third-degree unlawful possession of personal identification information and nine counts of fourth-degree criminal possession of stolen property.
The remaining charges are one count of third-degree grand larceny, nine counts of fourth-degree grand larceny, two counts of first-degree scheme to defraud and 10 counts of petit larceny. Together, the eight categories total 56 counts, matching the police announcement.
At arraignment, the court set bail at $10,000 cash, a $20,000 insured bond or a $50,000 partially secured surety bond. Court records list his next appearance as a conference on December 9 at 9 a.m. at Nassau District Court in Mineola.
The police announcement did not provide a total dollar loss or identify the purchases allegedly made with the cards. The charges are allegations, and Portnoy is presumed innocent unless convicted.
What to Do if a Card Goes Missing From Your Locker
The Federal Trade Commission advises reporting a lost or stolen card to its issuer immediately through the bank’s app or a verified customer-service number. Check the account for unfamiliar transactions and report any unauthorized charges as soon as you discover them.
Keep a record of when you noticed the card was missing and when you notified the issuer. The FTC recommends following up in writing and retaining copies of correspondence and notes from calls.
To limit what could be exposed if a wallet is stolen, the agency also recommends carrying only the cards you need and keeping PINs separate from your cards. If you suspect someone has misused your identifying information, IdentityTheft.gov provides reporting tools and a recovery plan.




