Stephen Baldwin is facing an insurer’s demand for more than $6 million after a bathroom fire sprinkler flooded a historic New Mexico hotel.
The case concerns the 60-year-old The Usual Suspects actor’s July 2024 stay at Hotel St. Francis in Santa Fe.
Westfield Insurance Company filed its negligence lawsuit in October 2026, according to USA TODAY. The company is seeking to recover money it says it paid hotel operator Heritage Hotels and Resorts Inc. for remediation, repairs and restoration.
Baldwin’s attorney, Ross Keiser, called the lawsuit “frivolous” in a statement to PEOPLE and rejected the suggestion that his client bears responsibility for the damage.
The Complaint Describes Damage Beyond Baldwin’s Bathroom
🚨 Hailey Bieber’s dad Stephen Baldwin sued for allegedly causing $6 million in damages to fancy hotel.
Exclusive: https://t.co/8ujjvxmjir https://t.co/XiY7T4gVdH
— TMZ (@TMZ) November 19, 2026
According to the complaint, Baldwin told hotel staff that he had accidentally struck the sprinkler head while using a towel. Westfield alleges that the resulting discharge spread into multiple guest rooms and hallways, damaging ceilings, walls and other parts of the property. The insurer argues that Baldwin failed to exercise reasonable care while using the room.
The property’s history stretches back to the De Vargas Hotel, which opened in 1889. According to Hotel St. Francis, a fire destroyed the earlier building in 1922, and the hotel reopened in 1924. Heritage acquired it in 2009 and began renovations.
Baldwin’s Lawyer Says Staff Couldn’t Stop the Water
Keiser said Baldwin immediately alerted hotel management when the sprinkler activated. The actor was subsequently told that employees could not access the maintenance room to shut off the water, according to the attorney.
Keiser declined to comment further while the case is in litigation. Westfield separately told the magazine that it does not discuss pending lawsuits.
The Case Has Moved to Federal Court
On November 18, Baldwin’s legal team removed the case from New York Supreme Court in Ulster County to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York. The Justia docket lists Anne M. Nardacci as the presiding district judge.
The parties must file a case management plan and exchange mandatory disclosures by December 30. An initial telephone conference is scheduled for January 6, 2027, before Magistrate Judge Miroslav Lovric.




