Tyreek Hill wants two phone calls recorded by his mother-in-law kept out of his divorce trial with Keeta Vaccaro.
The NFL receiver says Alesia Vaccaro recorded him twice without telling him or obtaining his consent. Hill filed a motion earlier this month asking the Florida court to prevent Keeta from using the calls at trial, according to TMZ.
The request follows earlier discovery disputes involving Alesia as well as a separate fight over Hill’s contact with another potential witness. Both issues have become part of the evidence battle surrounding the former couple’s case.
Vaccaro filed for divorce in April 2025 after police responded to their Sunny Isles Beach home. She later accused Hill of eight incidents of domestic violence during their marriage, allegations he has denied.
Hill Says One Call Included a ‘5,000 Baby Mommas’ Remark
The first recording dates to January 2024. Hill says Alesia confronted him about his relationships with other women and made a remark about him having “5,000 baby mommas waiting.” His filing argues that the conversation contains no discussion of “a single physical act.”
A second call took place in May 2024 while Hill and Keeta were arguing. Hill says he contacted Alesia himself because he hoped involving Keeta’s mother would help de-escalate the dispute.
Hill says he was in Florida during both conversations while Alesia was in Texas. According to his filing, she did not tell him that either call was being recorded, and he never gave permission for her to do so.
Hill Is Relying on Florida’s Communications Law
Hill’s motion cites Florida’s restrictions on intercepted communications. Section 934.03 of the Florida Statutes generally permits a private person to intercept a protected wire, oral or electronic communication when all parties have given prior consent, subject to exceptions spelled out in the law.
A separate provision says intercepted wire or oral communications cannot be received as evidence in a Florida proceeding when disclosure would violate that chapter.
Hill is asking the court to apply those provisions to calls that crossed state lines, with him in Florida and Alesia in Texas. The admissibility of the recordings is now one of the evidentiary questions before the court.
Hill Had Already Sought Records From Alesia Vaccaro
Alesia was already involved in a separate discovery dispute months before Hill challenged the recordings.
In a July court filing, Hill asked a judge to compel her to produce communications with Keeta, call records and other documents. He said the court had ordered the material turned over in early June and that he later agreed to a two-week extension.
Hill eventually asked the court to require production within one week. The request placed communications involving Alesia directly within the broader discovery fight before the dispute over the two recordings surfaced.
Hill Denied Trying to Influence Crystal Espinal Before Her Deposition
A separate September filing involved Crystal Espinal, Hill’s former partner and the mother of three of his children. Vaccaro questioned Hill’s renewed contact with Espinal shortly before she gave deposition testimony in the divorce case.
Wealth of Geeks previously reported that Vaccaro asked whether Hill or his representatives had offered Espinal money or another benefit and whether their contact influenced her testimony.
Hill denied trying to influence Espinal and asked the court to sanction Vaccaro and her attorney. His response argued that they had identified no threat, misleading statement or offer of a benefit intended to affect a witness’s participation in the case.
Vaccaro Filed for Divorce After Police Were Called to Their Home
Police responded to Hill and Vaccaro’s Sunny Isles Beach condominium in April 2025 after Alesia called authorities during an argument between the couple. No charges were filed, and officers left without further incident, according to Reuters.
Vaccaro filed for divorce the following day, saying the marriage was irretrievably broken. She and Hill had married in Austin, Texas, in November 2023.
In an amended filing later that year, Vaccaro alleged eight incidents of domestic violence during the marriage. The accusations included claims that Hill threw her to the floor during an argument over a postnuptial agreement and that some incidents occurred while she was pregnant.
Hill denied all eight allegations in a subsequent court response. His attorney, Julius B. Collins, also rejected Vaccaro’s accusations and said Hill intended to present his evidence in court.