A Towing Owner Was in Jail. Deputies Say He Told His Manager to Fake Flood Damage

Oscar Rodriguez
Image Credit: Oscar Daniel Rodriguez, pictured in Miami-Dade’s inmate-search record, faces organized fraud and grand theft charges in a case filed November 19, 2026. Image Credit: Miami-Dade Corrections and Rehabilitation Department.

A Miami towing company owner is accused of telling an employee how to fake water damage and increase rental-car bills during recorded jail calls. Detectives estimate that ASAP Towing overcharged four rental companies by $123,236.80.

Oscar Daniel Rodriguez, 37, faces one count of organized fraud involving $50,000 or more and one count of first-degree grand theft involving $100,000 or more. Both charges are first-degree felonies.

A November 18 arrest affidavit describes the calls alongside complaints from Avis and Sixt about efforts to recover their vehicles. Detectives subsequently collected billing records from four rental companies and compared the charges with applicable towing rates. The new Miami-Dade criminal case was filed November 19.

Jail Calls Described Making a Vehicle Look Flooded

Arrest-affidavit excerpt describing alleged instructions to simulate water damage and increase towing charges.
Rodriguez’s arrest affidavit describes recorded jail calls about making a vehicle appear water-damaged and charging rental companies extra. Document Credit: Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office / Miami-Dade Clerk of the Court and Comptroller.

The detective who signed the affidavit said he obtained recordings of Rodriguez’s jail calls after a July 2 arrest. He described conversations in which Rodriguez instructed his manager, Dany Carias, to overcharge rental companies.

In one conversation, Rodriguez allegedly explained how to make a vehicle appear water-damaged. Carias asked whether he should soak it to make it look flooded and justify additional labor charges, the affidavit says. The detective also described Rodriguez advising Carias to charge rental companies extra because they would pay to recover their vehicles.

Avis Was Quoted $15,476 to Recover Two Vehicles

An Avis security manager told investigators that a driver sent to collect two vehicles on September 4 was initially quoted $3,550 per vehicle. Upon arrival, the driver was told the total was $15,476.80 and that one vehicle had sustained water damage.

The manager reported being told that an Outlander had been recovered after sinking in water and that water-recovery charges started at $7,500. Avis’s roadside-service records listed illegal parking as the reason for both tows, according to the affidavit.

When the detective visited the tow yard on September 15, Rodriguez denied quoting $15,476.80 or discussing those vehicles with Avis. He said a different Avis vehicle had suffered water damage and had already been released.

Rodriguez then stated that the accumulated fees were $2,035.30, the affidavit says. The detective relayed that amount to Avis and told the company to arrange pickup.

A Claimed Police Hold Kept Sixt From Its BMW

A Sixt manager described repeated attempts to recover a BMW X1 from ASAP Towing. Employees allegedly refused to release it because of a police hold, but the detective’s records check found no such restriction.

After visiting the tow yard on September 23, the detective learned that the BMW’s location signal placed it in Hialeah. Investigators found Rodriguez in possession of the vehicle and arrested him for theft, according to the affidavit.

Four Rental Companies Supplied Records for 215 Vehicles

Affidavit excerpt showing investigators’ estimated overcharges for four rental companies.
Investigators’ affidavit lists estimated overcharges totaling $123,236.80 across Avis/Budget, Sixt, Hertz and Enterprise. Document Credit: Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office / Miami-Dade Clerk of the Court and Comptroller.

Investigators reviewed records from Avis/Budget, Sixt, Hertz and Enterprise covering 215 vehicles. Those records included towing and recovery dates, vehicle descriptions and amounts charged for release.

The affidavit estimates overcharges of $31,750 for Avis/Budget, $16,274.40 for Sixt, $44,998.80 for Hertz and $30,213.60 for Enterprise. Investigators said the amounts charged were approximately two to five times the towing costs they calculated.

Their analysis cited Miami-Dade’s rate schedule for qualifying private-property nonconsent tows, along with storage and administrative-fee rules. The Avis/Budget records covered slightly more than a year, according to the affidavit.

Rodriguez Pleaded Not Guilty to the New Charges

The court docket identifies the new case as F-26-022701. A November 20 entry records $15,000 bond on each of its two counts.

Rodriguez’s public defender entered a written not-guilty plea on November 20, requested discovery and demanded a jury trial. The clerk’s case summary still listed Rodriguez as in jail on November 22; he is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Check the Invoice and Verify Any Claimed Police Hold

Florida law requires towing operators to provide itemized invoices identifying actual charges, including the service and amount for additional fees. Miami-Dade County also says drivers or authorized representatives must be allowed to inspect a towed vehicle before payment.

If a company says police have blocked a vehicle’s release, contact the agency it identifies through an independently verified number to check the restriction. Preserve invoices, photographs and messages about disputed charges or the vehicle’s condition.

People who believe their towing rights were violated can contact the county’s Consumer Mediation Center at 786-469-2333. The county accepts supporting records with its consumer complaints.