He Was the Church Treasurer. Deputies Say He Took $81,213 From the Congregation

Tony Maylon Hall
Image Credit: Davidson County Sheriff’s Office.

A former North Carolina church treasurer is accused of taking $81,213.35 from the congregation’s funds. Investigators identified the suspect as Tony Maylon Hall, 71, of High Point.

The allegations involve Amity Baptist Church at 7967 N.C. Highway 109 in the Winston-Salem area of Davidson County. Deputies received a report of suspected embezzlement on September 18, 2026, according to the Davidson County Sheriff’s Office.

The sheriff’s Criminal Investigations Division investigated the complaint. Hall was arrested on November 17 and charged with felony embezzlement.

Warrant Says Hall Was Entrusted With the Church’s Money

Excerpt from Tony Maylon Hall’s arrest warrant alleging embezzlement of $81,213.35 entrusted to him by Amity Baptist Church.
The charging allegation in Tony Maylon Hall’s arrest warrant says he embezzled $81,213.35 that Amity Baptist Church had entrusted to him. Document Credit: North Carolina Judicial Branch, Davidson District Court.

The arrest warrant alleges that Hall received the church’s money into his care while acting as its fiduciary and then embezzled those funds. It identifies the amount as $81,213.35 and lists the alleged offense as occurring on or about May 17, 2021.

The warrant was issued on November 17, 2026, and the court docket records it as served that day. Davidson District Court case 26CR455559-280 contains one felony embezzlement count.

Court Records Show a $2,500 Bond Was Posted

A November 17 release order signed by Magistrate TK Brown set a $2,500 secured bond. The court’s register of actions records that a professional surety bond in that amount was posted on November 18.

In the release order, the magistrate recorded that Hall had no criminal history and no other pending charges. The order was issued in Guilford County on behalf of Davidson County, where the criminal case is pending.

Hall’s next appearance is scheduled for December 17 at 8:45 a.m. in Courtroom 1 at the Davidson County Courthouse. The November 21 court record lists the case as pending, and Hall is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

A Second Reviewer Can Help Protect Church Funds

The National Council of Nonprofits recommends that someone besides the designated bookkeeper review bank statements, even in very small organizations. It also advises establishing clear rules about who can access bank accounts and authorize spending.