He Was an 88-Year-Old’s Banker. Deputies Say He Took $26,500 to Pay His Own Bills

Corey James Sullivan
Image Credit: Nassau County Sheriff’s Office.

A former Truist banker is accused of taking $26,500 from an 88-year-old customer’s account through seven unauthorized withdrawals. Investigators say the transactions were followed by cash deposits into the banker’s own account.

Corey James Sullivan, 41, of St. Marys, Georgia, worked as a senior relationship banker at Truist’s Amelia Island branch in Nassau County, Florida. He was arrested November 19, 2026, and booked into the county jail.

Deputies responded to the branch on August 24 after a report of theft. The branch manager told them Sullivan had recently been fired following an internal fraud investigation, according to the arrest affidavit.

The customer told investigators he recovered all of his money but incurred legal fees in the process. The affidavit also describes a written statement in which Sullivan acknowledged taking money to cover household bills.

Affidavit Describes Sullivan’s Signed Statement About Family Bills

Redacted affidavit excerpt describing Corey Sullivan’s signed statement about taking customer money for utilities and mortgage payments.
Sullivan’s arrest affidavit reproduces portions of a signed statement in which he acknowledged taking customer funds for household bills. Document Credit: Nassau County Sheriff’s Office / Nassau County Clerk of Courts.

Detective D. McDonald obtained materials from Truist’s internal investigation, including records supplied through subpoenas. In the arrest affidavit, he describes a handwritten statement signed by Sullivan and witnessed by the branch manager, reproducing the portions he could read.

According to that account, Sullivan said he repeatedly took money from the customer’s account and deposited it into his own to help his family. He said the money went toward utilities and the mortgage, and that his wife was unable to work.

“I should not have done this,” the statement says, as reproduced in the affidavit. Sullivan also apologized and offered to sell gold and silver to replace the money.

Withdrawal Tickets and ATM Footage Formed the Money Trail

Redacted affidavit excerpt describing $26,500 in withdrawals and tickets bearing Corey Sullivan’s name.
The affidavit identifies seven transactions totaling $26,500 and says most withdrawal tickets displayed Sullivan’s name beside “prepared by.” Document Credit: Nassau County Sheriff’s Office / Nassau County Clerk of Courts.

The affidavit identifies seven withdrawals between May 5 and July 10, totaling $26,500. On May 5, it lists a $2,000 withdrawal from the customer’s account and deposits of $400 and $1,500 into Sullivan’s account that same day.

A June 3 withdrawal totaled $5,000, followed the next day by deposits of $1,500 and $3,500 into Sullivan’s account. The largest withdrawal was $7,000 on June 9; the affidavit describes smaller deposits into his account over the following days.

McDonald wrote that ATM footage obtained from Truist showed Sullivan making the deposits. Most of the withdrawal tickets also displayed Sullivan’s name beside the “prepared by” field, according to the affidavit.

The detective alleges Sullivan used the customer’s identifying information, including bank account numbers, seven times to obtain the money. He also described Sullivan’s use of a computer to carry out the alleged scheme.

Court Papers List 17 Charges and a December 10 Appearance

The arrest affidavit and first-appearance order list seven identity-theft counts and seven counts of uttering a forged instrument. The other charges are theft involving $10,000 to $50,000 from a person aged 65 or older, an organized scheme to defraud involving $20,000 to $50,000, and unlawful use of a two-way communication device.

The first-appearance order, filed November 20, requires Sullivan to have no direct or indirect contact with the customer. It also provisionally appoints the Public Defender’s Office to represent him.

The order lists his next appearance for December 10 at 9 a.m. in Courtroom A. Nassau County case 26CF000760AXYX remains pending, and Sullivan is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

Review Withdrawals and Report Transactions You Do Not Recognize

The Nassau County Sheriff’s Office says detectives believe there may be additional victims. Anyone who believes Sullivan victimized them can contact Detective McDonald at DA1565@nassauso.com.

Truist recommends regularly reviewing transactions and setting up account alerts through its Security Center. Customers can access that feature from the online banking dashboard or the mobile app’s More menu.

Report unfamiliar transactions promptly through the bank’s official fraud channel. Truist accepts reports for all claim types at 844-487-8478; have the transaction dates and amounts ready, and record the case number for follow-up.