Andrew Rannells says Kevin Spacey once asked him on a date in a handwritten letter following a backstage encounter during his Broadway run in The Book of Mormon.
The actor shared the story on the November 17 episode of The Downside With Gianmarco Soresi, saying he had never discussed it publicly before.
His account dates to 2011 or 2012, when he was playing Elder Price at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre. He received a Tony Award nomination for the role.
Entertainment Weekly contacted representatives for Spacey and fellow visitor Goldie Hawn for comment. Its report did not include a response.
An Unexpected Visit After the Broadway Show
Famous guests regularly visited Rannells and costar Josh Gad, sometimes without advance notice. After one performance, Rannells recalled opening his dressing-room door to find Hawn, Spacey and director Joel Schumacher. They had not attended together but walked backstage at the same time, leaving everyone crowded into the small room.
Rannells said Spacey began rubbing his neck while they stood there. Schumacher then told him, “Stay away from that man.” According to Rannells, Spacey heard the warning and replied, “Hey, come on. Come on.”
Schumacher had directed Spacey in the 1996 film A Time to Kill. The filmmaker died in 2020.
What Rannells Remembers About the Letter
View this post on Instagram
About a week later, Rannells said, the note arrived at the theater on letterhead from London’s Old Vic. Spacey was the institution’s artistic director from 2004 to 2015, a tenure confirmed by The Old Vic.
Rannells recalled Spacey praising his talent and described the note as “classy,” according to BroadwayWorld. “I just never responded,” he said, although he kept the letter for a long time.
How His View of the Encounter Changed
Rannells said the anecdote eventually “got less funny.” Public misconduct accusations against Spacey emerged in 2017.
Spacey was found not liable in Anthony Rapp’s civil lawsuit in 2022 and acquitted of all charges in his British criminal trial in 2023, according to The Associated Press.
In March 2026, he settled three additional civil claims brought by men in London. The settlement terms were not disclosed. Spacey has denied wrongdoing in those cases.




