Jenny McCarthy Says She Woke During $1,500 Implant Surgery at 19, Doctor Told Her She’d Forget

Jenny McCarthy
Image Credit: mwood99 / Shutterstock.

Jenny McCarthy says she woke up during a $1,500 implant operation when she was 19 and alerted the surgeon that she was conscious.

Now 54, the Masked Singer panelist revisited the experience on the November 19 episode of The Jenny McCarthy Wahlberg Show.

McCarthy had recently left college and was living on Chicago’s South Side when friends began traveling to Arizona for discounted procedures. Their results persuaded her to save up and make the trip herself.

Before the operation, she went skydiving. As Entertainment Weekly reported, McCarthy said she wanted to have done something adventurous in case the surgery went wrong.

The Surgeon Told Her She Would Forget

The doctor replied that he still had one side to complete and told her to stay calm, McCarthy recalled. She remembered him adding, “You won’t remember a thing.”

“I remember everything, buddy,” she said while recounting the exchange. McCarthy said she could still recall what he was wearing and described crying and moaning in pain as the procedure continued.

She also remembered arriving at the facility through a back alley, a detail she now believes she should have questioned before going inside.

Staff Raised the Table to Examine Her

McCarthy said the medical team secured her to the operating table and raised it upright. Staff then moved across the room to assess whether the results looked even while she remained restrained.

She remembered desperately wanting to go home. After the operation, she returned to her boyfriend and vomited repeatedly, describing severe pain during her recovery. She called the decision the “biggest mistake of my life.”

Her Results Were Larger Than She Requested

McCarthy said she had requested a small C cup but ended up with what she described as a double D. When she challenged the surgeon, he told her many patients eventually returned wanting larger implants, so he had chosen that size to spare her another operation.

She eventually turned to Dr. Terry Dubrow for a reduction in the early 2000s. During a separate November 3 podcast conversation covered by Wealth of Geeks, the two discussed that procedure and the additional operations he performed for her afterward.